Capitulation, Yes, But Resignation? Not Happening

Wall Street investors continue to deny and defy the grinding gyre of the Federal Reserve and its all-in all-out blitz to rid the economy of inflation. Wall Street Journal staffer

Here are a couple of additional perspectives on the level of capitulation showing its colors in the homebuilding community’s negative sentiment and outlook measures. Truman Patterson, Wolfe Research homebuilding and building products equity research analyst keys in particularly on deteriorating traffic signals in the HMI report. He writes:

More discouraging is the “continued decline in the ‘Traffic’ reading to 20 from 25, which likely weighs on December sales. We will be watching intently for a sequential improvement in the ‘Traffic’ reading next month given the slightly improved rate landscape. At the height of the GHR, we remind investors the Traffic reading fell to the HSD range for several months toward the end of 2008/early 2009. The ‘Traffic’ component averaged 30 in 2006, 21 in 2007 and the low teens in 2009 through 2011.

The October HomeSphere/BTIG builder survey corroborates weak and still worsening selling conditions and forecasts among operators:

• Sales and traffic trends are extremely soft: Only 7% of builders reported higher YOY sales vs. 42% in October 2021. 71% saw a YOY decrease in orders vs. 63% last month and 23% in October 2021. Only 11% reported an increase in YOY traffic vs. 12% last month. 70% saw a decline, compared to 61% last month.
• Sales and traffic relative to expectations also continue to weaken: A survey record-low 7% of respondents saw sales as better than expected, while a survey-record high 55% saw sales as worse than expected. Just 12% saw better-than-expected traffic, with 45% seeing worse-than-expected traffic.
• Price cuts and sales incentives are at survey record highs: The number of builders raising prices decreased to a survey record low and the number of builders lowering prices increased to a survey record high. 12% of builders raised some, most, or all base prices in October, from 24% last month, while 47% cut some, most or all base prices vs. 33% in August.

A homebuilding owner/principal of a enterprise on pace to recognize $800 million in revenues in 2022 tells us:

We think that, for us, what’s going on now is worse than what we had to deal with going into the housing collapse in 2007,” this privately-held chief executive says. “Back then, there were early warnings, and a slow, but sure signal that things were deteriorating. This time, the speed with which the market turned from a deep supply of high demand to nothing has been a shock. And even if the rate increases slow down, we’re not going to see anything much below a 6% mortgage rate for sometime, so I don’t see a quick comeback. We’re going to go through a tough 2023.”

The operative term here is this:

We’re going to go through …”

Sentiment is one thing. And in the face of an unyielding Federal Reserve effort to wring both inflation and its behavioral and psychological drivers – as well as their effects on cost-of-living – out of the economy, a bleak outlook among homebuilders mirrors consumer households’ crisis of confidence when it comes to committing to most of their lives’ most pricey and precious purchase.

That said, sentiment is not the same as resolve. Sentiment is not the same as determination and cunning, and a next-batch of survival steps many homebuilders know by heart. Many of them started their companies precisely at times like now, or steered them through the throes of other bumpy, discouraging times, and have lived to tell the tale again and again.

One top 200-ranked multimarket homebuilding enterprise ceo writes:

Over the last 8 years or so … I’ve read a lot of articles and attended a lot of conferences. And I’ve heard a number of so-called ‘experts’ proclaim that residential construction is a backwards, archaic industry that is ripe for disruption. What those experts fail to understand is that we deal with disruption all the time! In fact, we experience sharp downturns like this regularly, and we’ve built ourselves as an industry to weather those storms. There aren’t many businesses out there that need to plan for that kind of contingency, and I think a lot of industries wouldn’t survive the circumstances that we’re dealing with right now. We are surviving it, and we’re going to continue to do so in the future, but it doesn’t mean that the process of surviving won’t involve painful decisions.”

… I must say I am weary of hearing over and over how backward we are.  We are a resilient and nimble industry.  How many so-called ‘forward’ industries could handle what we face?  With only a blip on the economic horizon for them, have you taken a look at the tech industry? Wow!

Importantly, homebuilder sentiment and homebuilder capability and staying power amount to two entirely different things. The HMI’s validity is in its measure of the strength and signals of demand for new homes. It does not measure the canny, time-tested ways – lowering their costs, cutting their prices, simplifying products, refining their sales targets, reeling in their land holdings, etc. – leaders, owners, and stakeholders in homebuilding firms respond to shocks and stresses, frequently coming out stronger.